Home About EIA Latest News Campaigns Skills Sharing Visual Media Press What Can I Do Search Site Links

<< Back to homepage

05 March 2003

   - click to zoom image

THAILAND SENDS 100 TIGERS TO CHINA

A briefing regarding the 100 tigers that Sri Racha Tiger Zoo in Thailand exported to China.

China Imports 100 Tigers From Thailand


1. Background

On December 25th 2002, the Sri Racha Tiger Zoo in Thailand exported 100 captive bred live tigers to Sanya Love World in China. Media reports at the time speculated that the tigers were to be bred in captivity and their meat sold in the Sanya Love World’s restaurant, as a means to underwrite the cost of breeding the tigers.

Subsequently the Chinese company involved flatly denied such allegations and stressed that the import of tigers was “for non-commercial purposes”. The sale of tiger meat would be in violation of Chinese national legislation as well as non-compliance of CITES.

Under CITES, live tigers can be exported if they are part of a zoo to zoo loan, exchange or donation or if they are part of scientific captive breeding programme. These transactions would be classified as “non-commercial purposes”.

The CITES Secretariat has launched it’s own enquiry and is of the opinion that “the import of the tigers does not comply with the guidance on captive breeding that is contained in Resolution Conf. 5.10 (Definition of 'primarily commercial purposes').”

2. Conference Resolution 5.10

Under Conference Resolution 5.10, if the transaction were “non-commercial” the importing Party, in this case China, would need to prove that the tigers were imported for scientific purposes or for a captive breeding programme.

Scientific Purposes

Claims that the tigers were imported for scientific purposes would have to be supported by documentation that they had been imported by a scientist or scientific institution. The tigers could not be the resold, commercially exchanged or exhibited for economic benefit.
  • The Chinese Sanya Love World is not a scientific institution, but operates for public entertainment.

Captive Breeding Purposes

Claims that the tigers were imported for a captive breeding programme must be supported by clear indications of how that programme will benefit the long-term conservation of the species, and again there should be no economic benefit for the private individual or shareholder. They should be part of general programmes aimed at the recovery of the species and be undertaken with the help of the Parties in whose territory the species originate.
  • Since the tigers imported are from inbred hybridised founder stock, have not been bred in a scientific manner and are not part of an internationally managed studbook programme, they provide no conservation benefit.

  • The tigers in Sri Racha today are thought to be primarily Bengal tigers, yet there is no indication that consultation with India, Bhutan, Nepal and Bangladesh (range States) was conducted in advance of the trade.

  • The tigers in question could not be released in to the wild in China. Releasing captive bred tigers into the wild is a long complicated scientific process that has yet to be completed successfully anywhere. Sufficient well-protected forest is required. Two of the reasons China’s own subspecies, the South China tiger is on the verge of extinction are habitat destruction and poaching to satisfy global demand for skins and bones. There is no evidence to suggest either threat is under control.

  • Current captive breeding programmes in China feed tigers live chicken and cows to “train” captive bred tigers to hunt. To release tigers trained in this way would prove disastrous. Upon release such specimens would simply attack domestic livestock, bringing them into direct conflict with local people. The methods currently used in China for breeding tigers also mean that the specimens are habituated to people and for this reason would be unsuitable for release.

3. Concerns with the exporting facility, Sri Racha Tiger Zoo in Thailand

NGOs and captive breeding specialists have all raised concerns about the operation and purposes of Sri Racha Tiger Zoo and the many facilities like it in existence in Thailand and China.

According to a Thai government statement in 1995, the owner of Sri Racha has special status under a clause in the 1960 Thai Wildlife Law to keep a large number of tigers, but “without operating as a recognised breeding centre” and he is “forbidden from trading or selling the animals he possesses”.

In 1995, the owner of Sri Racha called for the law to be amended to allow trade in the tigers. The international community rejected this, but again in 2000 and 2001 various Thai politicians floated the idea (See the EIA report “Thailand’s Tiger Economy” www.eia-international.org )

There is a discrepancy between the number of tigers on show and the numbers the facility claims it breeds each year. In addition, some of the NGO concerns that the facility may be engaged in illegal trade were aroused as a result of there appearing to be only young tigers on display. Some enclosures contain more than 10 tigers, yet after the ages of 3 or 4, adult tigers no longer tolerate each other and become increasingly territorial. What, then, happens to the older tigers? The numbers simply don’t add up.

Furthermore, the IUCN Captive Specialist Group does not consider the specimens at Sri Racha appropriate for participation in international tiger breeding programmes - the stock Sri Racha began with was largely from Chiang Mai, known Indian-Indochinese hybrids, though the tigers at Sri Racha today are considered primarily Bengal tigers and are publicly known as such.

The CITES Senior Enforcement Officer of the Secretariat’s Legislation and Compliance Unit led the Thailand Tiger Mission in August 2002. The Mission report, presented to the 12th Conference of the Parties to CITES, highlighted a number of concerns regarding Sri Racha and facilities like it. (See CoP12 Doc.33 Annex on www.cites.org CoP12 Working Documents).

  • Sri Racha Tiger Zoo is not a member of the World Association of Zoos and Aquariums, it is a private commercial enterprise and is “essentially a place of public entertainment” complete with an exhibit showcasing their breeding programme with tiger cubs “suckling” on pigs and photo opportunities for the 1.2 million visitors it receives.

  • The tigers at Sri Racha came from a founder stock of two male and two female so-called "Bengal" tigers in 1987. In August 2002 there were over 350 tigers. Only four more tigers have been introduced to the original stock in that time.

  • The reasons given for continued breeding of the tigers at this rate are so that the facility can claim it has more tigers than anywhere else.

  • The CITES Tiger Technical Mission team “believes that the large number of tigers in captivity in Thailand and the significant amount of captive breeding that is taking place offers considerable potential for illicit activities”.

  • The CITES Tiger Mission to Thailand also considered the more general problem with the interpretation of “zoos” and trade for “non-commercial purposes” and noted in their report that “The team also had in mind some recent violations of the Convention where illicit trade in specimens of CITES-listed species, including some highly endangered Appendix-I species, has occurred where the trade purported to be of a scientific nature but had significant commercial aspects”.




< Back


  Species in Peril Campaign

Forests for the World Campaign

Global Environment Campaign

Climate Change


DonateJoin us

Subscribereceive regular updates from eia

shop


facebookVisit our page


twitterVisit our page



wordpressVisit our blog


youtubeVisit our page


Quick Search


advanced search


  Copyright © 1997- The Environmental Investigation Agency All Rights Reserved           Privacy | Home |

You are on the EIA–London site. Please visit the EIA–Washington site for additional information on EIA's global work.

EIA – London,
62/63, Upper Street,
London N1 0NY, UK
Tel: +44 (0)20 7354 7960
Fax: +44 (0)20 7354 7961
Email: ukinfo@eia-international.org
www.eia-international.org
EIA – Washington, DC,
PO Box 53343, Washington,
DC 20009, USA
Tel: +1 202 483-6621
Fax: +1 202 986-8626
Email: info@eia-global.org
www.eia-global.org